Pirates Open To Re-Signing Andrew McCutchen: A Look at the Options
After 12 seasons with the Pirates, Andrew McCutchen expressed his desire to return for another season, acknowledging his shortcomings in the 2025 season. With his age-39 season approaching, the question remains: what role will McCutchen play in the team's future? The Pirates have already addressed the designated hitter spot, but McCutchen's position is still uncertain.
During the PiratesFest fan event, GM Ben Cherington emphasized the team's focus on building a winning roster. He highlighted McCutchen's legacy and the importance of maintaining a good relationship with him. However, the Pirates are also looking to improve their offense, and McCutchen's role may be limited due to his age and performance.
McCutchen's 2025 numbers were underwhelming, with a 95 wRC+ and average Statcast metrics. As a designated hitter, his performance may not be sufficient, and the Pirates have already signed Ryan O'Hearn to fill that role. McCutchen's future with the team is uncertain, especially if the Pirates opt for a younger, more versatile player.
The Pirates' goal this winter is to improve their offense, and they have already signed several players to raise their offensive potential. McCutchen's desire to be part of Pittsburgh's next winning era is clear, but with seven straight losing seasons, the team's rebuild is ongoing. The Pirates may be hesitant to cut ties with a franchise icon, but they must make decisions that benefit the team's long-term success.
The Pirates' decision to re-sign McCutchen or move on from him will be a crucial one, and it remains to be seen how the team will navigate this situation. With the deadline for a deal approaching, the Pirates must make a choice that aligns with their goals and the player's desires.
